厙惇勛圖

Home   News   Features   Interviews   Magazine Archive   Symposium   Industry Awards  
Subscribe
厙惇勛圖
Leading the Way

Global 厙惇勛圖 Finance News and Commentary
≔ Menu
厙惇勛圖
Leading the Way

Global 厙惇勛圖 Finance News and Commentary
News by section
Subscribe
⨂ Close
  1. HomeRegulation news
  2. Bats and co take capital plan objection to court
Regulation news

Bats and co take capital plan objection to court


22 February 2016 Washington DC
Reporter: Mark Dugdale

Generic business image for news article
Image: Shutterstock
Opponents of Options Clearing Corporations (OCC) recently approved capital plan have taken their case to court in a bid to have the 厙惇勛圖 and Exchange Commissions (SEC) decision overturned.

Exchange operator Bats Global Markets, along with trading firms Susquehanna International Group LLP and KCG Holdings, filed a motion to block the SECs approval of OCCs capital plan on 12 February at the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.

OCC is poised to issue a $39 million refund to clearing members and distribute $17 million in dividends to stockholder exchanges, including Nasdaq OMX Group and Chicago Board Options Exchange, in exchange for capital, which will increase their equity from $25 million to $247 million. They will also have to replenish the OCCs reserves in the future.

Bats, Susquehanna and KCG disagree with the SECs decision to approve the capital plan because it is irrational to swap OCCs own funds for exorbitantly priced capital from the exchanges owners, according to court documents.

The capital plan will create an unfair advantage for a systemically important financial market utility such as OCC, according to the complainants, as it will also be able to implement a new fee schedule that will mark a 19 percent drop in cost.

OCC is the sole clearinghouse for exchange-listed options in the US and the capital plan, in essence, effectively allows its shareholder exchanges to monetise the OCC's monopoly over options clearing for their benefit, according to the complainants.

Under the approved capital plan, OCC will pay dividends at a level some 16 to 20 percent higher than current market rates, they argued.

At the heart of the groups argument to have the approval overturned is the SECs consultation process, which saw the US securities markets regulator receive a string of comments in opposition, all of which were largely ignored, according to Bats and its co-complainants.

The SECs approval contains factual errors, ignores relevant data, fails to engage in necessary economic analysis and does not consider reasonable alternatives, they argued.

Bats, Susquehanna, KCG and others contested the capital plan last year, citing policy and competition concerns. They managed to convince the SEC to implement a temporary stay while the plan was reviewed, but that was eventually lifted and the plan later approved.

Dismissing their petitions on 11 February, the SEC said given OCCs critical clearing functions and its systemic importance, the commission agrees that having OCC increase its capitalisation is appropriate and in the public interest.

The capital plan does not impose any burden on competition not necessary or appropriate in furtherance of the purposes of the [Exchange] Act.

Speaking on 11 February, Craig Donohue, executive chairman of OCC, commented: We are pleased that the SEC has granted final approval of OCCs capital plan.

Through this action, the SEC has confirmed that strengthening OCCs capitalisation is a compelling public interest and has acknowledged OCCs importance to the US financial markets as a systemically important financial market utility.

OCC has reportedly requested to be a party to the case. The SEC hasnt responded publicly to the case, while OCC doesnt comment on pending litigation.
← Previous regulation article

DC Circuit refuses to delay OCC's approval
NO FEE, NO RISK
100% ON RETURNS If you invest in only one securities finance news source this year, make sure it is your free subscription to 厙惇勛圖 Finance Times
Advertisement
Subscribe today
Knowledge base

Companies in this article
→ OCC

Explore our extensive directory to find all the essential contacts you need

Visit our directory →

Discover definitions, explanations and related news articles in our glossary

Visit our glossary →